On Christmas Eve 1914, along stretches of the Western Front in Belgium and northern France, the guns fell quiet. British soldiers peering over their parapets saw lanterns and small Christmas trees along the German trenches and heard men singing carols. By the next morning, in many places, soldiers who had been trying to kill each other days earlier were standing together in No Man’s Land, shaking hands, swapping cigarettes and burying their dead. The Christmas Truce has become one of the most famous episodes of the First World War. Like many famous stories, it has picked up myths along the way. Using letters and official war diaries, historians have pieced together a clearer picture of what happened and what did not.
The War in December 1914
When war broke out in the summer of 1914, many expected it to be over by Christmas. Instead, after the German advance was stopped at the Marne in September and both sides tried to outflank each other in the “race to the sea,” the fighting settled into lines of trenches running from the Belgian coast to the Swiss border. The British Expeditionary Force, a small professional army, had suffered heavy losses, including tens of thousands of casualties at the First Battle of Ypres in October and November.
By December, men on both sides were living in cold, flooded trenches, sometimes only a few dozen yards from the enemy. Close enough to shout to each other, soldiers sometimes did. Informal “live and let live” arrangements, such as not shooting at men collecting water or eating breakfast, had already appeared in some sectors.
Calls for a Christmas Pause
Earlier in December, Pope Benedict XV appealed for an official truce over Christmas, asking that “the guns may fall silent at least upon the night the angels sang.” The warring governments did not agree, and the idea seemed unrealistic. At the same time, both sides made great efforts to give their troops a sense of Christmas. In Britain, a fund in the name of Princess Mary, daughter of King George V, sent an embossed brass gift box to soldiers and sailors, typically containing tobacco or cigarettes, a pipe and a Christmas card. German troops received parcels from home and small Christmas trees, many of which were set up along the trenches.
Christmas Eve: Carols Across the Wire
On December 24 the weather changed. The rain stopped and a hard frost set in, firming up the mud. In many sectors firing slackened during the day. As darkness fell, German soldiers placed candles and lanterns on their trenches and decorated trees. Songs such as “Stille Nacht” (“Silent Night”) drifted across No Man’s Land, and British troops responded with carols of their own.
In some places, men shouted greetings and arranged not to shoot. German soldiers held up signs reading “You no shoot, we no shoot” or “Merry Christmas.” Gradually, small groups climbed out of the trenches and met halfway.
Christmas Day in No Man’s Land
On Christmas morning, encounters spread along parts of the British-held front. Soldiers exchanged cigarettes, tobacco, chocolate, food, buttons and cap badges. Some showed each other photographs of their families. Others cut each other’s hair or posed for photographs. Many letters describe how surprised the men were to find the enemy friendly and ordinary.
The truce also had a practical side. Many bodies had been lying in No Man’s Land for weeks, and in several sectors the two sides used the pause to bury their dead, sometimes in joint services. The pause was not complete or safe everywhere. The Commonwealth War Graves Commission notes that around 80 British and Commonwealth soldiers died on Christmas Day 1914, some from sniper fire in sectors where no truce took hold.
Did They Really Play Football?
The image of British and German soldiers playing football in No Man’s Land is the best-known part of the story, and the most debated. Official unit diaries rarely mention football, and many accounts written long after the war are unreliable. But several contemporary letters and diaries do describe kickabouts, some with real balls and some with tins or improvised balls. A German officer of the 133rd Saxon Regiment, Johannes Niemann, later described a game on frozen ground in which the Germans won 3–2. The war diary of the 2nd King’s Own Scottish Borderers records a game between the opposing sides. Other accounts mention planned matches that never took place.
Most historians now conclude that informal kickabouts probably did take place in a few places, but that a single organized match with teams and referees was unlikely. The idea of a “great match” grew mainly in later retellings.
How Widespread Was It?
The truce was neither universal nor uniform. It was most widespread in sectors held by British troops facing German units, especially Saxons and Bavarians, in Flanders and northern France. Estimates suggest that perhaps around 100,000 British soldiers were involved to some degree. In other sectors, war diaries record only a quiet day, no contact at all, or continued fighting. French and Belgian troops, whose countries were occupied, were generally much less willing to fraternize, though some local truces did happen on their fronts as well.
In some places the truce lasted only a few hours. In others it continued through Boxing Day or even into the New Year, as soldiers who had met each other were reluctant to resume killing. Eventually, orders, rotations of troops, and renewed shelling brought it to an end.
The Reaction of Commanders
Senior officers on both sides were alarmed. The commander of the British II Corps, General Sir Horace Smith-Dorrien, had already warned against fraternization before Christmas and demanded reports afterward. Some officers who took part were reprimanded, but few were punished seriously, partly because so many men had been involved. In the following years, commanders took steps to prevent a repeat, including ordering artillery bombardments over Christmas and rotating units.
There were small, scattered truces at Christmas 1915, but nothing on the scale of 1914. As the war dragged on through the massive battles of Verdun and the Somme in 1916 and beyond, bitterness hardened and the conditions that had made the truce possible largely disappeared.
How the World Found Out
Military censorship did not fully hide the truce. Soldiers’ letters describing it were published in British newspapers in early January 1915, sometimes alongside photographs. Some commentators praised the moment of humanity, while others worried it might weaken fighting spirit. In Germany, the press was more restrained. A young German soldier named Adolf Hitler, then a regimental dispatch runner, is reported by a comrade to have disapproved of the fraternization.
Why the Truce Still Resonates
Over the past century, the Christmas Truce has been commemorated in songs, films, plays and even advertisements. Memorials in Belgium, including a monument near Ploegsteert (known to British soldiers as “Plugstreet”), mark the places where it happened. Commemorative football matches were played for its centenary in 2014.
Historians caution against making the truce into a story of soldiers rejecting the war altogether. Most men went back to their trenches and continued to fight, many for years. But that is part of what makes the episode moving. For a short time, ordinary men who were caught up in a war few of them understood chose to meet as people rather than enemies. The details have sometimes been exaggerated, but the core of the story is confirmed by letters written within days, and it remains one of the most humane moments in a war that killed millions.
Sources
- Commonwealth War Graves Commission: Peace in No Man’s Land, the truth behind the Christmas Truce
- The Long, Long Trail: Legends, myths and realities, the Christmas Truce 1914
- Smithsonian Magazine: The Christmas Truce began on this day in 1914
Featured image: Unknown / Wikimedia Commons, Public domain