In the sunbaked caves of South Africa’s Karoo, centuries-old cave art quietly covers a sandstone wall, its meaning long disputed and its subject unknown. The creature is eerie: a tall-bodied beast with tusks that turn downwards, unlike any animal modern Africa recognizes.
For years, scholars dismissed the painting as a myth or misidentified creature, a walrus or long-lost legend. Yet recent discoveries have opened up the possibility of something so astounding it has left even experienced researchers reeling.
What if this ancient artwork is a window into a world that no human ever saw?
Why Does Cave Art Remain Relevant?
Cave art isn’t some static remnant of the past—it connects us to the minds of our early human ancestors.
From continent to continent, from France’s Lascaux to Australia’s Arnhem Land, they’ve informed our understanding of human creativity, cognition, and even evolution. Further, they document extinct animals, forgotten rituals, and the earliest flickers of symbolic thinking.
In the digital age, these tangible works of art continue to spark debate on social media, where users analyze their significance and wonder at their longevity. Cave paintings maybe simple pigments on rock, but it’s also humanity’s oldest memory, written in stone.
Who Solved the Mystery?
The breakthrough was the direct result of Professor Julien Benoit insatiable curiosity. A paleontologist at the University of the Witwatersrand in Johannesburg, South Africa, Benoit had become obsessed with the so-called “Horned Serpent” panel, a 200-year-old San painting in the Free State.
Earlier scientists had dismissed the tusked beast, but Benoit noticed something that others hadn’t. With a critical eye and scientific patience, he worked to unravel a riddle that had perplexed generations—one that would end up rewriting the history of art and science.
How Did Science Eventually Perceive What Was Concealed?
Understanding this discovery came down to new technology and old-fashioned fieldwork. New methods of rock art dating, like accelerator mass spectrometry, allowed scientists to date the painting more accurately than ever before.
Further, digital imagery and excruciating chemical analysis revealed details invisible to the naked eye. But it was context—the sheer abundance of fossils found in the Karoo soil—that gave Benoit his “aha” moment.
Sometimes, it takes both the microscope and a pair of muddy boots to shed light on what has been hiding in plain sight.
An Extinct Dicynodont in San Rock Art
What Benoit came to realise is that the painting likely depicts a dicynodont, a bizarre, tusked “mammal-like reptile” that went extinct over 200 million years ago—long before humans appeared.
The creature’s downward-tusking tusks, stumpy legs, and typical pose match fossilized skeletons found in the area. That means that the San artists, believed to be surrounded by fossilized bones, reconstructed and painted an animal no human had ever seen alive.
Their artwork precedes the first scientific description of dicynodonts by at least a decade, making this the world’s oldest known picture of an extinct species in human art. Experts have been left speechless at this discovery: did ancient artists practice paleontology before the word existed?
Who Were the San, and How Did They Make This Discovery?
The San, the oldest inhabitants of southern Africa, were observant about their world. Living in the Karoo, they hunted, gathered, and painted thousands of rock art. The San didn’t paint for decoration alone—their art was a form of storytelling, ritual, and record-keeping.
Benoit’s team discovered fossilized bones strewn about near the cave where the art has been painted, indicating the San didn’t merely encounter these remains; they examined them, tried to interpret them, and ultimately transformed them into myth and memory.
This revelation recontextualizes the San not only as artists but as the world’s first indigenous paleontologists.
Beyond Art: The Human Drive to Understand the Ancient World
This isn’t simply a matter of a single painting or a single extinct beast. The Karoo is a global hot spot of paleontology, and its fossils reveal the transition from reptiles to mammals.
Western scientists have combed these rocks for evidence of evolution for decades. But the San beat them to it, piecing together the story of extinct giants from the bones that surrounded them.
Their paintings, once dismissed as ritualistic mythology, are now evidence of a unprecedented level of ancient sophistication and advanced science, showing that curiosity and wonder are universal and can traverse both culture and time.
How Cave Art Has Informed Science
Cave art has consistently challenged our assumptions about early humans. The San’s dicynodont imagery shows that local individuals were aware of and depicted extinct creatures long before the advent of the science we now call paleontology.
This forces scientists to rewrite the history of discovery and the genesis of knowledge. It also highlights the need to respect and study indigenous traditions, which may hold more clues about Earth’s lost worlds.
The hysteria, both in the scientific community and on social media is telling—people sense that this is bigger than one fossil; it’s about who gets to tell the story of our world.
What Does This Bode for the Future? Will More Secrets Be Revealed?
If the San could recreate a 280-million-year-old beast from the bones beneath their feet, what else have we missed in ancient artworks? Researchers are already re-examining rock art in Africa and beyond, wondering how many other extinct creatures have been hiding in plain sight.
The discovery holds out new possibilities for archaeologists, paleontologists, and indigenous people to collaborate. It also leads us to reconsider what we dismissed as myth or legend. As arguments fire up on TikTok and Reddit, the question is: what stories are still waiting to be unearthed?
The Enduring Power of Curiosity: Why This Discovery Matters
Essentially, this is a story about humanity’s timeless urge to make sense of the unknown. The San artists who painted the dicynodont weren’t simply recording their world—they were reaching across millions of years, bridging the gap between what is and what was.
Their paintings tell us that science and imagination aren’t at odds but are instead partners in the quest to understand our place in the universe.
As researchers scramble to interpret our history, one thing is sure: sometimes the greatest mysteries are hidden not in words, but in the quiet testimony of ancient paint and rock.
Uncover more fascinating moments from history — and hit Follow to keep the stories flowing to your feed!
Don’t miss more incredible stories from the past! Tap Follow at the top of this article to stay updated with the latest historical discoveries. Share your thoughts in the comments — we’d love to hear your perspective!
